It's only eight days until joy, or else a gloom unto doom. Not Tuesday, Election Day, but the Day After.
In one sense, it's not the right time for the Kill Strike against Trumpism. The President will survive this humiliation and will remain in office, it seems no matter what, for two more years He will be wounded--privately, though publicly he will not own up to the personal nature of the defeat--and angry. Though he avoided it, showed little focus on it, and pursued policies ignorant of the effect upon it, it is still his, and he has delivered himself personally to his side in the end.
I think that it may work, to some extent. He is like the one with the whip hand herding his MAGA sheep into the voting booths. And some of those who were confused by the betrayal to their cause that his 2026 persona has brought will show up grumpily and help salvage a few of the races in play.
If that moves the national margin from 8-10%, where it has polled recently, to "only" 6 percent, there will be gloom. The key outcomes will not be settled yet--even in the House, though the Democrats will surely prevail there--and control of the Senate will be mired in a set of several too-close-to-call races which will decide it. Doom would not necessarily follow, but there will be no relief.
The argument for Joy, though, insists that this is the right moment, and this midterm and Donald Trump the right targets. As has been noted, the battle for Congress has become a "target-rich environment"* for the Democratic party. The Republican defenses have been softened by grassroots dissatisfaction among their supporters, both the temporary ones of 2024 and he longtime cultists who see that their values were betrayed by Trump policies exacerbating the difficulties in their lives. Even more critically is the cratering of support for Trump and his policies among Independents--this group increasingly decides all close elections. Democratic attacks have come from a number of angles, but the ones focusing on Trumpist grifting and outright theft and on the negative effect on cost of living arising from the unsuccessful Iran military adventure seem to have bit most broadly and deeply.
If we are to be joyful next Wednesday morning, we will need to see a couple of clear victories in Senate races to feel confident about it. I name Sherrod Brown in Ohio and the wins we should expect to see in in Michigan, Maine, and North Carolina. After that, we will win some and lose some, but hope would be justified.
Personally, I find the rejection of Trumpism apparent in this election to be insufficient. Even if the results meet my most optimistic hopes (240+ in the House, 53+ in the Senate, defeat of both Paxton and Greg Abbott), it will be because of economic weakness, a condition that can easily reverse and bring a political reversal as well, and not because of the many, serious areas of damage Trumpism has caused and may continue to cause for at least two more years, nor because of the demonstration, once and for all, that this Republican party can't govern. Even if Democrats win clear control of both houses of Congress, this win is not going to mean permanent defeat for the party of Trumpian losers, just yet.
I hold by my predictions of two months ago, though now they look to be on the pessimistic side.
*Reference to former Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld, always done ironically. Rumsfeld felt Iraq was a target-rich environment and Afghanistan was not. So, I guess it wasn't just about 9/11.


